Posted on November 19, 2026
|
5864 words
|
Nate Rhone, Cyle Pool, Erich Trowbridge
Ogres Review
Video
Intro
What this army is about (Styles, tricks, or “thing” they do):
CP: They concentrate force into incredibly efficient break though units paired with the durability of ogres! It's got some tricks that seem obvious but catch people off guard every time.
ET: Ogres in previous editions was about destructive power. In 4th , for me, they are the SUPRISE_I_WIN scenario masters.
NR: An army to swiftly punch your enemy to death. Pretty straight forward no nonsense with some interesting ways to enforce your will. Maximum aggression is the name of the game. On almost every unit you're gonna find brutal and crushing. Making them a good army against higher defense opponents. Though a lot are defense 4 or 5 meaning they do take some hits. Overwhelming attacks, strong double charges and chaff play is key to keeping units up and producing past round 4ish.
Models (Mantic and 3rd Party)
CP: Mantic ogres rule as long as you enjoy belts. If you don't enjoy belts you won't enjoy their line. If I was doing it all over I would probably use conquest orcs which are about ogre scale.
ET: Mantic has carried a competent ogre line for a long time. I actually prefer the GW fat ogres aesthetic myself.
NR: Mantic has a line, I wish I could find something in the 3rd party world to their Siege Breakers. I love their shields. That being said, the world of 3rd party models for this is HUGE. Ogres exist from GW to DnD and about any gaming system you want out there. The world is your oyster on this to find something that really speaks to you.
Commands & Unique Spells
Protect the Tribe [5+]: Unengaged units, or units that have received a Charge! order this Turn only. The unit gains the Vicious (Combat) special rule. If the target unit is Engaged in a Combat involving another friendly unit with the Goblin Trait, add +1 to the dice results when issuing this order.
CP: If I'm charging, the math says use this ability. I've even used it on troops!
ET: Kinda the default I AM NOW PUNCHING STUFF order. In line with what we see in other factions. The charge req is a bit limiting, but probably fair overall
NR: A great choice for a charging unit. Very few units in ogres have vicious so a great way to put in on and it's never a bad thing to have.
Smoke Bombs [4+]: Units with the Tribal Strength or Goblin Trait only. The unit gains the Stealthy special rule until the start of its next Turn.
CP: If you need it, use it, but I don't go out of my way to force defense commands if I have offensive options on deck.
ET: Traditionally ogres have been super easy to shoot, being h3/4 across the board. This is a lovely command to help the army against shooting. Useful frequently at the end of the game when you don't want that unit wavered in crunch time.
NR: Nice defense as you are closing in for the punching phase as the majority of the army is speed 6ish and charging a gun line can take a bit.
That’s Our Stash [4+]: The unit gains +1 Unit Strength until the start of its next Turn.
CP: Wanna win the game? Do your friends hate whimsy? 10/10 command
ET: Sneaky game winner that your opponent will forget about every single time.
NR: Fun lil game changer on those missions where you are needing that lil boost to win an objective.
Goblin Explosives [5+]: When this unit makes a non-spell ranged attack in the Ranged Phase this Turn, each successful roll to damage that scores a natural 6, causes 2 damage instead of one.
CP: it's fun to use on the prep turns like 1 and 2. Once the armies touch, this command really gets benched.
ET: If you're running a bunch of shooting, this command is great. But If you're running a bunch of shooting, why aren't you playing elves or goblins?
NR: a chance for some extra wounds if you have some ranged. It is what it is.
Marching Orders [4+]: Large Infantry only. When this unit is issued an At the Double! order, it can make one additional pivot during the move.
CP: This wins games and buys insane board space. You ever seen an ogre horde pivot go 12 pivot? You will.
ET: Again, this is a sneaky game winner your opponent will forget about. This allows easy redeployment of your forces in the beginning of the game. This enables the sneaky "dodge that line of sight" move in the late game scrum when most units are off the table. Along with Green Rage and Ultimate Betrayal, Marching Orders is a S-tier command that will win games when used cunningly.
NR: Handing out extra pivots is always a game changer. Facing means the world in this game and anything you can do to get more facing changes then your enemy is always gonna be huge.
Steppe Storm (2) [+25] 18" CC: Instead of causing damage, if any hits are scored, until the end of its next Turn, the target unit rerolls any natural to-hit rolls of 6 for both Ranged and Combat attacks. The second result stands.
CP: This spell sleeps harder than me after Thanksgiving. 0/10
ET: UNELITE, in spell form, failing 25% of the time, hanging off a now-150 point platform. Thematic, but not for the number-crunchers among us.
NR: Nothing about this spell makes me wanna take it. The only way I'd consider is to have an argument with an orc player about if this would negate Green Rage.
CP: If you don't take hordes, you're probably taking her.
ET: Rallying budget warlord
NR: Cheap warlord
Value:
CP: Cheap, good, and rally. Nothing to be upset about.
ET: I play this unit. I like her muchly. RALLY is so so good in the ogre army. Mom's only D4 though, so don't plan on getting her stuck in and winning grinds. 165 points and Very Inspiring? YES PLEASE.
NR: Cheapest in the warlord section. Rallying and very inspiring is a nice lil touch and adding on a chariot for the price of a base warlord is fun. In an elite priced army being able to save points in places is something to consider.
Warlord [Warlord Hero (Lrg Inf)]: Warrior Hordes
Role within the army:
CP: If you want to play Cyle-Style, he is your boy.
ET: Ogre warlord with deep nerve.
NR: Warrior Horde unlocker
Value:
CP: D5 cs2 7dice with 17!!! NE. He is thicc chaff and a disgusting flanker. If you have him, you're taking hordes and hordes need chaff.
ET: 180 points for 7 top-class attacks, US2, inspiring and 3 command dice. Unlocks hordes, if this is your jam. All warlords feel overcosted, and this one is no exception. I think he's too expensive, which means he's probably properly costed. Unless I'm running hordes, there are better options? 17Ne is deep. This is the unit that looks meh oh paper but plays great on the table.
NR: This is one of 4 unlockers in the army, the other is Grok to move Siege breakers to Special from support. He is nice, again a lower cost then some of the other warlords but unless you wanna do warrior hordes there are more interesting options. Does have an option for crush 3 but lowering to Def 4 is a gamble that you might lose them as 7 attacks is hard to kill on a single round.
Nomagarok [U] [Warlord Hero (Lrg Inf)]
Role within the army:
CP: Min max a gunline
ET: Caster
NR: Nom Nom warlord caster.
Value:
CP: Unless you're going max warlock spam I can't find a home for Nom unless you're drowning in shooting like the SE and need the heal.
ET: Role is unclear. Nom has been mandatory in every ogre list since 2nd. I can't figure out where she goes now. 3 spells, bloodrage, master of the plains, and only 6 turns in the game. Give this unit 3 more rules and I still pass at 215 points.
NR: For casting you get 2 units to do it, Nom and Warlocks in champion. Noms casting is interesting, the only unit that can heal outright, Bloodrage is another way to hand out Vicious to a unit with honestly a much easier path then the command. Master of the Plains adds dice if you keep Nom near other ogres and can take that heal from 4 dice to 7 dice with no points spent. Plus bane chant and lightning bolt for free for 35 more pts then the warlord. Pricey but keeping up that hunter or zerker reg with 10 wounds on it so they can keep doing work is really something to consider.
Grokagamok [U] [Warlord Hero (Lrg Inf)]: Siege Breakers as specialist
Role within the army:
CP: Look up GOAT in the dictionary
ET: The goat
NR: Bread and butter smasher
Value:
CP: "Tactical nuke" with the ability to flank things
ET: Absolute Legend. The hardest hero in Panathor and Mantica before that. Everybody has a story about that one time Grok soloed their infantry horde. The greatest ogre there ever was. If you don't run Grok in your list… I'm sad for you. You must hate fun. 40mm base goated fits everywhere. Hits hard. Expensive. Worth it.
NR: 7 attacks on 3s with blast D3 Crush 3. Not an individual. Getting a side charge with Grok you're gonna be hard pressed to survive it. A one man wrecking crew but at 255pts he better be. Can also unlock Siege Breakers to Specialist.
Warlord on Chariot [Warlord Hero (Cht)]: Warrior Chariots are Core
Role within the army:
CP: Need for Speed the Game
ET: Go fast in extravagant fashion.
NR: Core chariot unlocker
Value:
CP: The Day we get Chariot Hordes back he becomes good.
ET: Core chariots for that all-chariot ogre alpha list you've been planning.
Sounds fun as hell. I gotta get on that brush.
NR: Unlocks chariots not hordes. No additional attacks, thunder 1. Can do the same Def 4 for crush 3. If I felt stronger about chariots I'd be all for it but I don't so this isn't for me.
The Big Deal [U] [Warlord Hero (Ti)]
Role within the army:
CP: My hobby hero
ET: Centrepiece warlord
NR: No
Value:
CP: None.
ET: Discord amongst rules writers but this guy is the weirdest of all places. He's slower than the normal mammoth. At 320 points, this guy should be hitting on 3s. The Mantic monument to Jesse Cornwell is in disrepair.
NR: Just no. There is no reason for this in any shape or form, they took the first ever model I ever painted for Kings and thankfully gave me a reason to never put him on the table again cuz the paint job is just the worst.
Champions
Ogre Warlock [2] [Champion Hero (Lrg Inf)]
Role within the army:
CP: Dakka! And support magic
ET: Less zappy than prior
NR: Hero caster
Value:
CP: Take 0 or 3 and define your list around it. In my opinion melee is a better suite for ogres right now.
ET: These guys were all over 3rd, chucking LB all over the place. Unclear what the value proposition is at 125. They inspire and that's cool. I can see building a list with a couple of these nerds to inspire stuff and toss fireballs around. 125 is a lot of points and that platform is before the spells.
NR: The only hero casting option. Has power of the plains as well for added dice which can turn that drain life into 8 dice. Expensive like everything else in the army so carrying more then 1 spell gets super pricey fast. I normally take 1 with drain life on it for some healing since they cant carry bane chant or a straight heal.
CP: A better BSB with the absolute best ability in the game. I don't take a 2nd without Doc. He's still not cheap.
ET: Doc is an amazing unit with a legit learning curve. Insanely good support piece at a great price for what he's bringing. The +2 Ne activates when Doc activates, so no fair running him 12" in some direction to give a far off unit +2.
NR: With the addition of the Doc upgrade this has moved into a very strong contender to see the table with a lot of regularity. I even made a special token for the nerve +2 that he can give out. 150pts is the only way you should consider the cost of this for a very inspiring BSB. Seriously overpriced vs other armies BSBs but the Nerve hand out can change the course of a game.
Boomer Sergeant [2] [Champion Hero (Lrg Inf)]: Heavy Crossbow upgrade
Role within the army:
CP: Elite wasp
ET: Shooty jerkface
NR: Ranged hero
Value:
CP: I struggle to waste a hero slot on a warmachine with legs
ET: Sh4+ is annoying. Interesting that they moved crossbow guy off of sarge and put it on this guy. Makes sense to me. Sh4+ is annoying. Not sure the math is mathing for your ogre gunline. This guy doesn't inspire - hard to justify a non-inspirational command unit.
NR: Can make him a xbow or boomer which is a nice change. That being said, I wish they "did" something to the units they represented if you wanted it for theme? A shooting elite aura or a piercing 1 aura or a stealthy aura would be nice? Though that would push their price up a lot.
CP: Any time I need another hero I start here then work up
ET: This nerd is the inspire stuff and find flanks guy. Nasty. I would absolutely consider this guy as a paymaster alternative if I have extra points. Elite always performs with Me3.
NR: Warrior hero, can put him on a chariot, Though, I'm sorry, chariots in this game on a whole just do not feel worth it. Spd 8 feels good for them but ok you get a huge base and thunder 1. For the cost they push up, they don't seem to get extra attacks, they dont seem to get anything other than that thunder which I hate thunder. Thunder is just sad, counts for 1 round only there are more than a few ways to block it from terrain to phalanx to ensnare. There is no way to block crushing. It just feels like crushing's younger cousin that tries but still fails. Sergeant is fun and can be a reasonable(for this army) price choice for some inspiring. But there are better choices looking at warlocks and Paymasters.
Berserker Bully [2] [Champion Hero (Lrg Inf)]
Role within the army:
CP: Flank and Spank. He is the definition of a value add unit
ET: Offensively minded sarge
NR: Zerker unlocker
Value:
CP: A quick fearless unit to play the mission, kill chaff, and find flanks. Great unit and I love 1 with pipes for brutal 2.
ET: Ain't a hero so much as a 40 mil missile.
NR: A Hero that does unlocks at 165pts. I do enjoy some Braves, though I like the troops of them too and this only unlocks regiments. Oddly enough from a math standpoint this does about half the attacks of the troop with an extra crush and inspiring for 15 more points. Not a bad trade off. But again if you're not interested in core regiments of braves it's hard to seriously consider this unit.
Arokamorra [U] [Champion Hero (Lrg Inf)]
Role within the army:
CP: Has absolutely no value in the game right now
ET: Who?
NR: Hunter elite without inspiring
Value:
CP: NONE. You can't take that many points, a hero slot, and not inspire
ET: With the premium for command units, lack of inspiring makes this otherwise attractive lady unplayable.
NR: Why. The brutal +1 aura is something to consider. Slayer D6 and a 12 inch ranged attack. The 50mm base is rough, and No inspiring on a hero?????? The Biggit in support can at least inspire goblins! No inspiring makes this not even an option to make it to the table.
Core
Red Goblins [Core (Inf) Regiment(aux)/Horde]
Role within the army:
CP: Goblins but better and worse at the same time
ET: Shooting phalanx
NR: Cheap base infantry
Value:
CP: Pseudo cheap things that score, shoot, and love to have cav bounce.
ET: Too many rules and no clear role. Points possibly better spent elsewhere. I can see some builds wanting a horde or two of these guys to camp objectives.
NR: I love they get such low esteem that a reg is considered Auxillary and the horde is 165 pts. They get short bows and phalanx. I still think they are overpriced for attacking on 5 and shooting on 6 with only 20 attacks. The shooting is just so you might have something to do with them in round 1 but they should be moving forward. I just think they gave them shooting so they could get the price high enough to not be offering a horde option at 130-140pts.
Warriors [Core (Lrg Inf) Troop/Regiment/Horde]
Role within the army:
CP: Optimal base line unit
ET: Your army core
NR: The core unit of the army
Value:
CP: At every level and load out this unit oozes value. 2h upgrade horde? Sure. D5 regiment with 17 nerve? Yes please!
ET: These guys are a steal at 185 and 130 for the reg and troop respectively. The geometry on the LI reg is so so good. Fits everywhere and is easy to prevent opponents from fitting. I'm way too lazy to do the math, but I would wager that the ogre reg has the best wound/PerPoint/PerMM in the game. These guys were built to fight in a phone booth.
NR: Welcome to the core unit of the army. Take 10 troops and watch your opponent go cross eyed. Take a horde or 2 and play hulk smash. I constantly go back and forth about the lowering Def to 4 for a extra crush. It feels like they melt pretty quick when I do that.
Boomers [Core (Lrg Inf) Troop(Aux)/Regiment]
Role within the army:
CP: Flex shooting and pressure point
ET: Bulk short-range shooting
NR: Short range ranged
Value:
CP: If you're going for a stall wall I LOVE boomers. You support them with Goblin regiments and warrior troops. Can be very disgusting but the list has to be built around them. 1 for fun brings very little to the table.
ET: Is shooting good? Is 12" shooting good? These guys are good at 12" shooting so if you think 12" shooting wins games, you should take some of these fellows.
NR: Most expensive core unit. Melee stat line is 18 attacks hitting on 4s(which is rough) Def 4 with crush 1. Shooting on 4s with piercing and range 12. I've tried to put these guys in but they never made it, it's just not my play style.
Hunters [Core (Lrg Inf) Troop/Regiment]
Role within the army:
CP: Unique chaff
ET: Luxury warriors
NR: Faster core with some twists
Value:
CP: Fast and flexible with good board play. But I think they struggle in regiments and as an army theme. Take a few at most.
ET: These guys can cook, but you're going to pay for it. 25 points for ensnare, pathfinder, S7 and Slayer3 while losing D5. I'm not convinced. Every stray bowshot on the battlefield gets spit at these guys.
NR: Oh I love hunters. In 4th I've started to love warriors more for the price but that ensnare is so so good. Killed a heavy cav reg with a troop of hunters before. Alex is still mad about it like 8 months later. The key to these guys is the ensnare. It totally changes the math of an enemy attack. Stack it with some terrain fun and suddenly they just can't touch you. They stay on the table a lot longer than a warrior unit does. Slayer 3 adds a lil extra fun vs those bigger monster type stuffs.
Red Goblin Scouts [Core (Cav) Troop(Aux)/Regiment(Aux)]
Role within the army:
CP: The fast troop of kings!
ET: Speed 10!
NR: Chaffffffff
Value:
CP: They are speed 10, wide, and cheap. You can't go wrong here. Ignore the regiment.
ET: I like the troops as a chaff option, along with warrior troops. Cav troop can usually chaff two units if the opponent is careless. The regiment is also playable at 150 in a geometry play.
NR: both sizes are aux, but at 105pt speed 10 nimble, troops make some wonderful wonderful chaff. I carry 2-3.
Red Goblin Scout Sniffs [Core (Cav) Troop(Aux)]
Role within the army:
CP: ??????
ET: Who?
NR: Shooting chaff?
Value:
CP: Take scouts, save 10 points, and add more to the board at the same time
ET: Unclear where this unit fits in the current build. Maybe get a shooting turn before chaffing?
NR: Only in troops. They can shoot and have feint but i dont need to spend more for a unit to die.
Specialist
Shooters [Specialist (Lrg Inf) Troop/Regiment]
Role within the army:
CP: Artillery
ET: Long range pressure
NR: Ranged attackers
Value:
CP: I do not like this unit, I do not think it has a role right now.
ET: Is shooting good? Is long-range pressure shooting the key to your cunning plan? Do you enjoy sitting in a mudpuddle and delivering 4 wounds a turn to d5 units in the wide open? If your answer is "yes" to these questions, you've probably never played Kings of War.
NR: I try to use them now and again. Same melee stats as a boomer but shooting 6 and reload so they cant really move. But 30inch range and piercing 2 make them do some work. Get them on a hill and let them stand there till turn 4-5 when you can charge in a fresh unit to finish some weakened things off.
ET: 30 points for fearless, wc d3, and 3 additional hits. You also get a point of nerve and lose d5. The only reason I can see to take these guys is to give them some spendy items and leverage the 30 attacks. I don't hate them.
NR: You can make these core with a bully, it's a fun alpha strike list and the crush 1 adds a bit of spice that some of the other zerker type units don't have and 30 attacks sees you rolling a ton of dice, but they die super fast too. Wild charge D3 does help with their threat range a bit. A fun unit to build a live fast die young list with.
Boomer Chariots [Specialist (Cht) Regiment]
Role within the army:
CP: Nothing
ET: Weirdo relic from 3rd
NR: A shooting chariot, yay?
Value:
CP: Nothing
ET: This unit exists because you can take a mantic boomer and put it on a mantic chariot and have a new unit type. These guys actually have more efficient pure shooting than boomers on foot, so I guess this is the play for your 12" shooting ogre army that will drive away all before it? These dudes have 6 attacks in melee.
NR: Why do these suck so badly? I've tried them a few times and wow. They have a huge footprint to get charged. And 6 whole attacks in melee is just wrong on every level. I thought it was a typo. Crush 1 NO Thunderous on a chariot. I just don't get it.
Warrior Chariots [Specialist (Cht) Regiment]
Role within the army:
CP: Fancy cav
ET: Aaw yeah
NR: Melee chariot
Value:
CP: Its a neat fancy cav unit with H4 to allow for layered combats. But it hits softer then cav on the alpha and is harder to multi charge with
ET: Solid cav unit that has some grind to it. Comparable to all the normal cav units and compares favorably. These guys look fun and I'll probably paint a bunch for some fluffy drunkhammer games. With the hindering rules as they currently stand, it's unclear how competitive these guys will be.
NR: Its a slightly faster 30 pt more expensive warrior with thunder 2 on a bigger base. In an army where every point counts, if I cant alpha strike with this unit its gonna be a hard sell to me.
Support
Siege Breakers [Support (Lrg Inf) Troop/Regiment]
Role within the army:
CP: C-4, they make a hole where u want a hole
ET: Solid superhammer
NR: Defense tar pit that's surprisingly offensive
Value:
CP: A very strong unit but slower than your army. One regiment is a terrifying center and d6 is hard to break from the front. The days of an army of these i think has gone however
ET: I'm told that bigshield is bad, but I don't believe it. I'm more daunted by the S5 these guys get. Deltas from warriors: 40 points for CS2, bigshield, headstrong and lose a point of speed. The unit lacks the tribal strength tag, so it can't get the stealth command. The unit is absolutely playable and is a solid choice. I think Big Shield is good. I think CS2 is good.
NR: 225 is a hard price to get, but I played with them a lot in 3rd, the spd 5 doesn't seem to be a big change but it turns out to be, if something that should be taking the brunt of a big unit getting them there can be hard. One of the few units that have a natural crush 2 on it hitting on 3s they do some work offensively. Big shield is fun as well. Headstrong is a nice addition as well as they are a target of shooting a lot. They tend to draw a lot of attention and are normally targeted early. Defending their flanks is important and having a healer or life drainer nearby is good but they are NOT tribal strength trait so they cant give dice to casters.
Red Goblin Biggit [2] [Support (Hero(Inf))]: Fleabag upgrade
Role within the army:
CP: GOD manifest
ET: Speedy jerkface
NR: Give him a slap and send him to die
Value:
CP: The broadest piece of chaff for 95 points money can buy! Use it, abuse it, stick in the way. Absolute GOAT. This unit allows you to deliver charges unhindered, sit in the way, tie up threats, and MOST importantly for ogres, this is THE answer to flyer spam. They get behind you but then are stuck. Never leave home without this man!
ET: Lazy general's Mr. Fixit. This is a worse fleabag troop - mostly because of base size. Zero percent chance this guy can chaff two units. I'm not feeling it, but I see why people would want to take him.
NR: On a fleabag he's a spd 10 lil chaff monster for 95 pts, 10 less then the scout sniffs. It's support so takes a lil more to get them out, though the general dearth of support options makes it not terrible to do for at least 1. Also doesn't have a wide base so is a lil easier to get around though with the speed getting them in close to make it hard to get around is pretty easy. For extra fun, rallying is great if you run them with scout sniffs and they inspire goblins so you can force extra nerve check rolls on chaff, maybe saving them to chaff more.
Red Goblin Blaster [2] [Support (Mon(Cht))]
Role within the army:
CP: Slot Machine
ET: Boom boom
NR: Goblin silliness to make your opponent stress
Value:
CP: It's scary to see, but never count on it to deliver a punch. The threat of the unit is often worth far more than the unit itself. I say take 1.
ET: Great unit actual game changer. There are a lot of lists that just can't deal with this second line unit and will just have to take it in the face. This unit plays much better in goblins, but I don't hate it in Ogres.
NR: I love them and always run 1 if I can. They are cheap at 80 pts and can do real damage if done correctly. 3 attacks hits on 3s with blast D6 with crush 3. Get this into a side, threaten things with it, it has to be taken seriously. In a side or rear charge, it will devastate just about any unit on the board. 3 dice to hit with blast D6 not much comes out of that. It does blow up after it hits in melee and only nerve 10 means it doesn't survive being attacked first. It's a high risk high reward piece but at 80pts this is a game, have some fun.
Red Goblin Slasher [Support (Ti)]
Role within the army:
CP: Flex Titan
ET: Colorful auxiliary unit
NR: Shooting monster
Value:
CP: Man, I wish it was better than Mid. Of the 3 titans I dislike it the least for ogres.
ET: I like this guy at 205 points - he's always doing something. The shooting attack is annoying. The damage profile on 10 attacks with CS2 Ne18 with D5 is the bermuda triangle of feeling too-cheap and too-dear at the same time. Which means it's probably perfect.
NR: the thrower on it with a range of 36 2 attack blast D3 pierce 2 can be fun. Height 5 makes it good to see a lot of the board. It's not gonna devastate anything in a round but might waver a chaff, and the 10 attacks crush 2 and strider make it ok to bring into the fight but at 205 pts thats more then a reg of warriors. Hard sell.
Giant [Support (Ti)]
Role within the army:
CP: Anvil with good calves
ET: He big
NR: It's a giant
Value:
CP: Right now it's too expensive to be a good anvil and it's never been a hammer. In ogres I just find better uses for 225 points if all you want is an anvil.
ET: There's a lot of giant hate because everybody wants them to be a hammer - but they are not. They are an unreliable 4.5 wounds. They are an effective anvil, but the 75 mil base means they will get flanked or wrapped without appropriate support. Thematically, I love these guys. Competitively, they are lost in the current rule state.
NR: I used to discount this out of hand, but to be honest I've built a few lists with it and it feels interesting. 20 nerve and D6+8 attacks with crush 4? Add either rampage or slayer depending on what you're facing more of and it might be kinda fun. The hits on 4 is an issue.
Mammoth [Support (Ti)]
Role within the army:
CP: Its role is to let you down
ET: Striding in!
NR: Just stop its sad
Value:
CP: None. Damn things broken.
ET: It hurts my brain to contemplate all the angles on this guy. CS2TC2? Check. Weird base size? Check. S8WC1? Check. Brutal (2) … wth? Where's brutal 2? I should get brutal 3 for 250 points on 6 hits. I'll never take this dude because I'll never remember all the rules. The mammoth was the butt of a joke in 2016 and nothing has changed. There's no reason to take this guy.
NR: Hits on 4s with 12 attacks. Yes it has rampage and spd 8 but all it's gonna do is charge something, maybe kill it then get multicharged back and die. The 80x100 is huge and is just asking for a side and front charge that will quickly overwhelm it. The 250pt price in an elite army is something that is hard to take.
Conclusions
How good the army is within the game: compared to other armies
CP: Awesome army for brand new players! Then you hit a wall and the army is just brutal to try and play at a higher level. It's where veteran players come to test their skill ceiling. Easy to play, VERY hard to master. The army is loaded with tricks and traps once you move past make a wall of smashy dudes. I think any player who wants to really get better at the game should have to at least play ogres for a while. You cannot make mistakes and still expect to win. But if you play well, very few armies have an answer for you.
ET: It's ironic that this is the army commonly started by new players due to overall model count. Really, this is an elite army that will go as far as the general can take it. This is not a list that tables opponents. This is a list that grinds out mission wins with a great set of commands. The list shines against shooting armies and alpha. It struggles to remove deep nerve pools and infantry hordes. I think ogres are a top5 army as currently constructed, based on the strength of solid core choices and superb commands.
NR: 3rd edition I learned the game with this army and lost for 8 months straight. Now I was playing against people like Erich and Cyle so it was a lot of learning games. I am blessed as a newish player with the group of people I get to play against who are so amazing at the game and yet so welcoming of new players and encouraging without being condescending. I look forward to games with Erich and Cyle because I will most likely lose, but I'll pick up a thing or 2 and they will offer a few ideas or point out other options after the game that gets me to think in new ways. And they do this in a supportive and enthusiastic way. As to the army in 4th it feels in an odd place, it feels like there are some questions that other armies can bring that I am hard pressed to have answers for but the questions this army gives can be a strong case as well. I feel momentum with this army is key and being aggressive putting your opponent on their back feet is how to win. This army doesn't do patience.